Pets offer us companionship, joy, and even health benefits, with new research highlighting the protective effects of dog ownership on brain health. Recent findings suggest that owning a dog could significantly reduce the risk of dementia, while the benefits for cat owners are less clear.
Dogs: A Brain-Boosting Companion
A major UK study, part of the English Longitudinal Study of Ageing (ELSA), tracked over 7,000 older adults over four years and found that dog owners have a 40% lower risk of developing dementia compared to those without pets. The study, published in JAMA Network Open in 2023, revealed that dog owners who were socially or physically active—such as walking their dogs regularly or socializing at dog parks—had an additional 20% reduction in their dementia risk.
Why are dogs so effective in protecting brain health? The key lies in their active lifestyle demands. Dogs require daily exercise, which keeps their owners physically active and helps preserve cognitive function. Regular walks, playtime, and even socializing with fellow pet owners can combat cognitive decline. The responsibility of caring for a dog also provides mental stimulation, keeping the brain engaged.
Cats: A Mixed Picture
In contrast, the benefits of cat ownership for dementia prevention are less evident. The ELSA study found no significant link between cat ownership and a reduced risk of dementia in the general population. Unlike dogs, cats don’t require as much physical activity, which could explain why their owners don’t see the same cognitive benefits.
However, there is a silver lining for people living alone with a cat. The study showed that individuals living in isolation with either a dog or cat experienced slower declines in memory and verbal fluency compared to those without pets. For these individuals, the companionship of a cat, with its soothing purring and affectionate moments, can help reduce loneliness—a known risk factor for dementia.
Pets and People with Dementia
Pets can also enhance the quality of life for individuals already living with dementia. According to Alzheimer’s Society, caring for a pet can boost self-esteem, encourage independence, and provide emotional comfort. The routine of feeding, grooming, or simply stroking a pet can help keep individuals engaged, while the unconditional love of an animal brings joy and laughter.
For some individuals with dementia, however, owning a pet may not be feasible. Alzheimer’s Society recommends considering whether the person has the mental capacity to manage the responsibilities of pet care, such as feeding and grooming. For those who can’t take on the demands of pet ownership, alternatives like animal visits, robotic pets, or cuddly toys can provide similar emotional benefits.
One touching example is Cheryl Yates, who gave her father, Robert Wyatt, a robotic cat in his final weeks. Robert, who had dementia, believed the cat was real and named it Buddy. “He was so happy to have a kitty again,” Cheryl shared. “This cat gave him so much comfort and joy.” This story highlights the emotional benefits pets—whether real or robotic—can provide.
Should You Get a Pet?
For those considering a pet to support brain health or improve quality of life, dogs seem to have the advantage, especially for active individuals. The physical activity and social interaction that come with dog ownership align with lifestyle factors that protect against dementia.
While cats may not offer the same broad protective effects as dogs, they can still be valuable companions, particularly for those who live alone.
Before adopting a pet, it’s important to consider the responsibilities involved, including the time, care, and financial commitment required. Not everyone, especially those with or at risk for dementia, can manage the demands of pet ownership. For those who cannot, options like pet therapy visits or robotic animals can offer similar emotional support.
The Bottom Line
The science shows that dog ownership offers a 40% reduction in dementia risk, driven by the active, social lifestyle that comes with having a dog. While cats don’t provide the same broad benefits, they can still offer emotional support, especially for people living alone. Whether it’s a wagging tail or a purring cat, pets can enrich our lives—and potentially protect our brains.
For more information on pets and dementia, visit Alzheimer’s Society or consult with your GP about lifestyle changes to support brain health.
Related topics:
AI Outperforms Humans in Selecting Future Service Dogs, Study Finds
Dog Overcomes Paralysis: A Story of Unyielding Determination
Superhero Therapy Dog Saves Life with Emergency Blood Donation
